When Credit Goes Private
- Alessandro Spina · University of Technology Sydney
- Sascha Steffen · Frankfurt School of Finance & Management, CEPR
- Daniel Streitz · Halle Institute for Economic Research, Friedrich Schiller University Jena
Preliminary draft, Nov 2026
Abstract
A growing share of corporate lending has moved from traded syndicated loans to private credit. We ask what happens to the information in loan prices when credit goes private. Our laboratory is Business Development Companies (BDCs), which report a quarterly fair-value assessment (“mark”) for every loan. Some of their borrowers also have loans with daily dealer quotes (“lit” loans), but most do not (“dark” loans). Marks on lit loans move roughly one-for-one with the loan market; marks on dark loans move only about a third as much and still trail the market a year later. The gap holds within firms that go dark and is not explained by differences in borrowers’ market exposure. Dark marks add nothing to market prices in predicting distress, yet lenders’ spreads at origination sort credit risk as well for dark as for lit borrowers: the lender appears to keep the information, but the mark does not pass it on. Stale marks transfer wealth between fund investors: those who redeem in a selloff exit above the value of the underlying loans, and those who subscribe in a recovery overpay. We estimate the transfer at up to $1.2 billion. As credit goes private, information about credit risk does not disappear but reaches outside investors late and incompletely.
SSRN version forthcoming.
Keywords: private credit, business development companies, BDC, fair value, loan marks, stale pricing, syndicated loans, direct lending, information, fund flows